Skip to main content

Table 5 Comparisons of observed and predicted valuations by state.

From: Reconsidering the use of rankings in the valuation of health states: a model for estimating cardinal values from ordinal data

  

Rank model

Time trade-off model†

State

Observed*

Predicted

Difference

Predicted

Difference

21111

0.864

0.908

-0.045

0.850

0.014

11211

0.860

0.947

-0.088

0.883

-0.023

11121

0.841

0.880

-0.039

0.796

0.045

12111

0.823

0.862

-0.039

0.815

0.008

11112

0.818

0.896

-0.078

0.848

-0.030

12211

0.754

0.809

-0.055

0.779

-0.025

12121

0.734

0.742

-0.008

0.692

0.042

11122

0.712

0.776

-0.064

0.725

-0.013

22112

0.656

0.666

-0.010

0.675

-0.019

22121

0.634

0.650

-0.017

0.623

0.011

21222

0.543

0.631

-0.089

0.620

-0.077

11312

0.542

0.502

0.040

0.485

0.057

12222

0.534

0.585

-0.051

0.585

-0.051

22122

0.518

0.546

-0.027

0.552

-0.034

21312

0.511

0.411

0.101

0.416

0.095

22222

0.495

0.493

0.002

0.516

-0.021

11113

0.383

0.520

-0.137

0.414

-0.031

13212

0.377

0.349

0.028

0.329

0.048

13311

0.323

0.344

-0.021

0.342

-0.019

12223

0.206

0.209

-0.004

0.151

0.055

11131

0.202

0.458

-0.256

0.264

-0.062

21323

0.149

0.147

0.001

0.128

0.021

32211

0.135

0.252

-0.117

0.196

-0.061

23321

0.134

0.133

0.001

0.150

-0.016

21232

0.058

0.209

-0.151

0.088

-0.030

22323

0.042

0.009

0.033

0.024

0.018

22331

-0.009

0.066

-0.075

-0.003

-0.006

33212

-0.025

0.023

-0.049

0.015

-0.040

11133

-0.054

0.209

-0.263

0.028

-0.082

21133

-0.068

0.118

-0.186

-0.041

-0.027

23313

-0.069

0.005

-0.073

0.037

-0.106

23232

-0.094

-0.053

-0.040

-0.126

0.032

33321

-0.133

-0.101

-0.032

-0.095

-0.038

22233

-0.146

-0.073

-0.072

-0.181

0.035

32313

-0.153

-0.106

-0.047

-0.098

-0.055

32223

-0.186

-0.116

-0.070

-0.163

-0.023

13332

-0.226

-0.071

-0.155

-0.115

-0.111

32232

-0.231

-0.164

-0.067

-0.261

0.030

32331

-0.276

-0.168

-0.107

-0.248

-0.028

33232

-0.331

-0.288

-0.044

-0.371

0.040

33323

-0.383

-0.349

-0.034

-0.331

-0.052

33333

-0.540

-0.540

0.000

-0.594

0.054

  1. *Mean observed time trade-off value †Time trade-off model based on Dolan [30]