Skip to main content

Table 5 Comparisons of observed and predicted valuations by state.

From: Reconsidering the use of rankings in the valuation of health states: a model for estimating cardinal values from ordinal data

   Rank model Time trade-off model
State Observed* Predicted Difference Predicted Difference
21111 0.864 0.908 -0.045 0.850 0.014
11211 0.860 0.947 -0.088 0.883 -0.023
11121 0.841 0.880 -0.039 0.796 0.045
12111 0.823 0.862 -0.039 0.815 0.008
11112 0.818 0.896 -0.078 0.848 -0.030
12211 0.754 0.809 -0.055 0.779 -0.025
12121 0.734 0.742 -0.008 0.692 0.042
11122 0.712 0.776 -0.064 0.725 -0.013
22112 0.656 0.666 -0.010 0.675 -0.019
22121 0.634 0.650 -0.017 0.623 0.011
21222 0.543 0.631 -0.089 0.620 -0.077
11312 0.542 0.502 0.040 0.485 0.057
12222 0.534 0.585 -0.051 0.585 -0.051
22122 0.518 0.546 -0.027 0.552 -0.034
21312 0.511 0.411 0.101 0.416 0.095
22222 0.495 0.493 0.002 0.516 -0.021
11113 0.383 0.520 -0.137 0.414 -0.031
13212 0.377 0.349 0.028 0.329 0.048
13311 0.323 0.344 -0.021 0.342 -0.019
12223 0.206 0.209 -0.004 0.151 0.055
11131 0.202 0.458 -0.256 0.264 -0.062
21323 0.149 0.147 0.001 0.128 0.021
32211 0.135 0.252 -0.117 0.196 -0.061
23321 0.134 0.133 0.001 0.150 -0.016
21232 0.058 0.209 -0.151 0.088 -0.030
22323 0.042 0.009 0.033 0.024 0.018
22331 -0.009 0.066 -0.075 -0.003 -0.006
33212 -0.025 0.023 -0.049 0.015 -0.040
11133 -0.054 0.209 -0.263 0.028 -0.082
21133 -0.068 0.118 -0.186 -0.041 -0.027
23313 -0.069 0.005 -0.073 0.037 -0.106
23232 -0.094 -0.053 -0.040 -0.126 0.032
33321 -0.133 -0.101 -0.032 -0.095 -0.038
22233 -0.146 -0.073 -0.072 -0.181 0.035
32313 -0.153 -0.106 -0.047 -0.098 -0.055
32223 -0.186 -0.116 -0.070 -0.163 -0.023
13332 -0.226 -0.071 -0.155 -0.115 -0.111
32232 -0.231 -0.164 -0.067 -0.261 0.030
32331 -0.276 -0.168 -0.107 -0.248 -0.028
33232 -0.331 -0.288 -0.044 -0.371 0.040
33323 -0.383 -0.349 -0.034 -0.331 -0.052
33333 -0.540 -0.540 0.000 -0.594 0.054
  1. *Mean observed time trade-off value Time trade-off model based on Dolan [30]